Popular Books and Occasional Papers
The results of Archaeological Investigations
The Archaeology of Patterson Village
Author William (Bill) Finlayson takes this simplistic definition, yet extraordinarily complicated field of study, and gives us a fascinating look into a piece of local Ontario history. Through the meticulously documented and analyzed “objects dug up from the ground,” we learn how the people of Patterson Village worked and socialized. Dr. Finlayson’s wonderfully descriptive prose, illustrations, and pictures, transport us back in time to the mid-1800s where we have a front-row seat to the lives of the people of Patterson Village.
Read more
The Archaeology of Patterson Village – A 19th Century Company Town in the Township of Vaughan, Ontario represents the largest excavation of a 19th century Euro-Canadian site in Ontario to date.
Between 1856 and 1888, Thomas Patterson and his brother operated one of the first farm equipment manufactories in the Township of Vaughan, Ontario. Patterson was a paternalist capitalist and established a company town which included 18 homes for married workers, and a boarding house for single men. For two years, This Land Archaeology Inc. worked on the complete excavation of the village. Findings included 16 cellars, and 36 privy pits in the subsoil. The excavations produced 291,911 artifacts as well as an estimated 1,113,097 small artifacts and preserved plant remains.
“For the academic audience, the material presented in the Patterson Village book is invaluable for addressing issues of village layout; organization of domestic, industrial, and institutional (post office, church, and school) space; the relationship between the capitalist entrepreneur and the workers; expressions of identity through material culture; worker health and hygiene; and day-to-day life in a village devoted to industrial output.
The public audience will undoubtedly find the volume of immense interest simply because it is an important part of Ontario’s history that has not been presented before in an archaeological and historical context. Colour plates of some of the 300,000 artifacts recovered, together with historical images, all of which are contextualized individually within features and buildings found during excavation, add to the allure of the book as something distinct from a local history volume.
I am confident the reader will enjoy this book immensely. The weaving together of history, oral history, and archaeology, serve to engage the audience and demonstrate the value of an interdisciplinary approach in understanding our collective heritage.” (2017: viii-ix)
John Triggs, Ph.D.
Associate Professor, Chair,
Department of Archaeology and Heritage Studies
Wilfrid Laurier University
Waterloo, Ontario
July 6, 2017
The Archaeology of Five Queensville Farmsteads
William (Bill) Finlayson once again brings the past to life. This time, it is through the lives of the generations of people who settled in Queensville, Ontario. The Archaeology of Five Queensville Farmsteads – a 19th Century Crossroads Community in the Township of East Gwillimbury, Ontario affords us a glimpse into what life was like for the master builders of the Sharon Temple, a unique architectural structure in Canada. We learn how they, their families, and many others who built the community and made it their home, lived.
Read more
This crossroads community of Queensville, Ontario, was settled early in the 19th century primarily by Quakers; they were part of the Great Migration of about 20,000 people who fled the United States because of religious persecution. Some of these early settlers were actively involved in the Children of Peace, a break-away sect of Quakers who constructed the Sharon Temple.
Between 2008 and 2017, Bill’s company, This Land Archeology Inc. excavated five farmsteads south of the crossroads on both sides of Leslie Street. One of these farmsteads was owned for a time by Ebenezer Doan, one of the master builders of the Sharon Temple, and another by his son, Ira, and grandson, Ezra. The excavations produced tens of thousands of artifacts, cellars, and associated features including privies for each farmstead. These findings provide new insights into life in 19th century Queensville.
“That is precisely why, as an historian, I am quite excited by Bill’s series of books. He writes from anarchaeological perspective, carefully limiting his conclusions to the physical evidence. In this study, he augments those findings through cross-referencing them with the detailed diary from 1871 by Ezra Doan that has been previously been published. An historian in the making, I’d say.
Indeed, this is the significance of these two studies [Patterson Village and Queensville Farmsteada] Finlayson has reviewed the physical evidence of two settlements, contemporary in time, close to one another by location, but different in their occupational purposes. One is a farming settlement that resulted from a breakaway religious movement that included in its community a Quaker master builder. The other evolved into a grouping of farm houses but had begun as an agricultural implements manufacturing complex owned by a compassionate entrepreneur. The homes, out-buildings, cisterns, and outhouses were similar; the artifacts of glass, iron, and ceramics were those traded across the colony or were locally-made tools. He is describing both the particular and the general, in design, in community, in social and work life, in family structure, daily life and hygiene—a complex tale from their detritus just as it could once be seen in their architectural design, construction, building materials, and settlement patterns.
This is an interesting and rewarding study. I have enjoyed it; so will you “ (xiii-xiv).
Bruce Bowden, Ph.D.
Port Hope, Ontario
June 28, 2018
The Archaeology of Two Whitchurch-Stouffville Farmsteads
In The Archaeology of Two Whitchurch-Stouffville Farmsteads, Bill shares that in the second half of the 19th century, John Yake Sr., a prominent Stouffville businessman, purchased two parts of Lot 32, Concession 10, in what is now the Town of Whitchurch-Stouffville. John Yake Sr. rented the small house at the western end of the lot, which eventually became the Yake site. John Yake Jr. lived on the western part of the lot, initially in the large house which became the Windmill site, and ultimately in a new brick house which was still occupied at the time of our excavations.
Read more
The Yake and Windmill sites were situated on former agricultural fields of the dwellers of the Mantle site, a large Indigenous village occupied in the sixteenth or early seventeenth centuries and currently located less than a km to the northwest of Lot 32. Excavations of the Windmill site recovered a spear point about 10,000 years old, which was likely collected by the Yake family while farming their land and subsequently discarded when filling in the cellar of the early log house at the Windmill site.
“While this book is shorter than the volumes on Patterson Village and Queensville Farmsteads, my goal is again to take the results of this project back to the general public and to provide the developer, Fieldgate Developments, with some value added for their investment in investigating the history of this property. The outcomes of our assessments are all too often detailed in licence reports filed with the Ministry of Tourism, Culture and Sport with no further dissemination to the general public.
I hope you will agree that our efforts to investigate the Yake and Windmill sites provides new insights into the 19th century occupation of what is now the Town of Whitchurch-Stouffville. William D. Finlayson (2019: xi).
The Archaeology, History, and Architecture of The Philip Eckardt Log House
Our Lands Speak (O.L.S.) is a prolific quality publication series founded in 2017 by William D. (Bill) Finlayson and issued on subjects in and affecting Ontario archaeology. The goal: to create additional space to disseminate information about Ontario’s rich archaeological history, including both historic and prehistoric archaeological investigations, as well as important First Nations perspectives. The Archaeology, History, and Architecture of The Philip Eckardt Log House – The Oldest House in the City of Markham, Ontario, Canada, continues to reflect Bill’s dedication to making archaeological findings available to the general public and to interested researchers.
Read more
George W.J. Duncan, co-author of The Archaeology, History, and Architecture of The Philip Eckardt Log House, is an architectural historian interested in the documentation of Ontario’s heritage buildings, local history, and cultural landscapes. Over four-plus decades, he has authored several books and numerous articles on these subjects, as well as on issues concerning heritage conservation. His best-known work in print is York County Mouldings from Historic Interiors, originally published by the Architectural Conservancy of Ontario in 2001, with a second edition published by Lee Valley Tools Ltd.
“George Duncan has captured the complex history of the Eckardt family, some of it based on verifiable facts and some of it rooted in family folklore, and he’s put this wealth of information into a compelling narrative of a vanished past. George has taken a careful look at the remarkable architectural history of Markham’s oldest house and worked to fit together the pieces of a challenging puzzle.
Two centuries or more of this early farmstead’s history are brought to life with William Finlayson’s detailed account of the extensive archaeological investigations that were carried out in the vicinity of the Eckardt Log House in 2012. Rarely do we see such a thorough analysis of an historic farmstead that combines the history of a family, a building, and its archaeological context in one document. Evidence for two historic kitchen wings and numerous features of interest in the surrounding landscape, were revealed by the excavations that greatly enhance our knowledge of the lives of those who lived here.
The City of Markham can be proud of its efforts to save significant and representative samples of early architecture, with the Eckardt Log House as its premier example. These buildings provide a physical representation of how the early and later settlers lived and progressed as their wealth improved. These windows to the past become ever more valuable as we advance into the future. This book provides one of the most vivid pictures we have of a first settler family, their changing accommodation, and their lifestyle. This is particularly relevant today as we see the increasing development of Markham’s first-class farmland that provided the livelihood of generations of subsequent settlers.” Lorne Smith, Official Historian, City of Markham, 2021: viii-ix).
The Keffer Site and the Indigenous Occupation of the Central North Shore of Lake Ontario in the late 14th and early 15th centuries A.D.
The Archaeology of the Keffer Site and the Indigenous Occupation of the Central North Shored of Lake Ontario in the Late 15th and early 16th Centuries A.D. is a companion publication to Finlayson and Lerner’s 2024 in-depth academic study of the Keffer archaeological village and the pre-contact occupation of the central north shore of Lake Ontario.
Read more
Circa A.D. 1525, about 10 years before French explorer Jacques Cartier visited Hochelaga on Montreal Island, four communities of Iroquoians and Algonquians on the north central shore of Lake Ontario experienced a massive shift in their way of life. Previously, they lived in small villages with little concern for defense. On the Don River, this resulted in the occupation of the Keffer site, a large village that was surrounded by intricate palisades with houses arranged in such a way to assist in their defence against attackers who managed to infiltrate the interior of the village, The Keffer settlement was the complex result of many ongoing processes that we have only begun to explore and understand, Herin is an introduction to this still unfolding story.
“Its terrific, read it” Elaine Dewar
Early Palaeo-Indian Occupation in the Rice Lake, Otonabee River, and South Kawartha Lakes Watersheds, South-Central Ontario-Research Since 1976
Foreword by Jonathan C. Lothrop, Ph.D., Curator of Archaeology, New York State Museum. Preface by William D. Finlayson, Ph.D., F.R.S.C., Founder of Our Lands Speak Book Series and Occasional Papers in Ontario Archaeology.
Our Lands Speak Occasional Papers in Ontario Archaeology is a superior quality publication series issued on subjects in and affecting Ontario archaeology. The goal of the series is to create additional space to disseminate information about Ontario’s rich archaeological history, including both historic and prehistoric archaeological investigations, as well as important First Nations perspectives. Another objective of this series is to make use of current advances in publication technologies. The print versions of the Occasional Papers include high quality colour illustrations, which few North American journals or monograph series currently offer.
Read more
Lawrence Jackson, Ph.D., is one of the foremost Palaeo-Indian scholars and author of this first Paper in Our Lands Speak Occasional Papers in Ontario Archaeology series, Early Palaeo-Indian Occupation in the Rice Lake, Otonabee River, and South Kawartha Lakes Watersheds, South-Central Ontario-Research Since 1976. He trained as a graduate student in archaeology at Trent University, Ontario, and began field work in the 1970s on sites of diverse time periods—petroglyph sites in Nova Scotia, a contact period village in Simcoe County, subarctic caribou interception sites with the National Museum of Canada, and Early Palaeo-Indian research for the Royal Ontario Museum on the shores of glacial Lake Algonquin near modern Georgian Bay.
The Draper Site, An Ontario Woodland Tradition Frontier Coalescent Village in Southern Ontario, Canada: Looking Back, Moving Forward
The Draper site, excavated in 1975 and 1978, remains the largest and most significant Iroquoian site subject to salvage excavation in southern Ontario. In this innovative study, Dr. William D. Finlayson reviews more than 40 publications, theses, articles, and unpublished reports as a prelude to the reconsideration of some of the key aspects of the site. This includes presentation of a new sequence of expansions of the village, new perspectives on the use of defensive strategies in the planning of the village, and the presence of menstrual houses. Draper is used to define a specialized type of coalescent village, the Frontier Coalescent Village. This study provides new insights into the coalescence of at least five smaller villages, some from Duffin Creek and some from further afield at Draper, and the special mechanisms which made this possible and sustainable.
Read more
On a broader scale, the Draper site is situated among the almost 50 Iroquoian sites currently known on the Duffin Creek. A major conclusion of this study is that this drainage was occupied by one or more communities of Iroquoians who were not Huron-Wendat, but rather a community of Iroquoians ultimately contemporary with the Huron-Wendat confederacy which occupied Huronia in the 17th century. The use of Michi Saagiig oral histories provides new evidence in support of the migration theory for the occupation of south-central Ontario by Iroquoians in the latter part of the first millennium A.D. Comparisons are drawn to the Iroquoian occupation of the Crawford Lake area where there was also a long occupation by Iroquoians, at least one community of which were also not Huron-Wendat. The study also elaborates on the Ontario Woodland Tradition as an organizational concept to replace the Ontario Iroquois Tradition.
Between 1975 and 1978, one of the most significant Iroquoian sites in the North America was excavated north of Toronto under the direction of William D. Finlayson. This was a rescue excavation since the site was located on property proposed for a new Toronto International Airport. Known as the Draper site, this project is important for several reasons. It was the largest Iroquoian site to be fully excavated. It was also the first time computer-assisted recording was used to map and mange the information on more than 170,000 analyzable artifacts, plus data points for the thousands of features, from a site 4.25 hectares in extent – truly a monumental undertaking.
Draper was a site that grew through a process of coalescence. What began as a modest village-size community with eight long and mid-sized houses grew through a series of five expansions into a town of more than thirty houses as well as an adjacent outlying village with at least six houses. For the first time, we could see how an Iroquoian community grew and changed over time. In addition, the computerized information makes it possible to pinpoint particular artifact types and styles. This gives us the ability to reconstruct who lived in and used these structures, an analytical tool that parallels the expansion of the site as different groups of people joined together to create it.
An initial report on this massive project was published in the National Museums of Canada Mercury Series in 1985. In itself, this was an amazing accomplishment – to process the information from such a large and complex site and publish a detailed report in less than ten years. Now, some thirty-five years later Finlayson has published a new volume summarizing the Draper site more completely and placing it within the context of other Iroquoian and Algonquian site in southwest Ontario.
Taken together, the Draper project – Finlayson’s two outstanding reports as well as the dozens of specialized studies, theses, and dissertations this project has enabled – remains one of the most valuable archaeological records of northern Iroquoian people yet produced. Even more exciting, much of that story remains to be told as students and scholars continue to study this amazing site. Thanks to Finlayson’s dedication and persistence, that ongoing work is still possible.
James W. Bradley, Ph.D.,
Director emeritus
R.S. Peabody Museum of Archaeology
Andover, MA
The Keffer Site: 15 th and 16 th Century A.D. Ontario Woodland Tradition Frontiers, Communities and Coalescence on the Don and Upper Rouge River Drainages, Southern Ontario, Canada
The Keffer site, excavated in 1985 and 1988 remains one of the most significant Frontier Coalescent Ontario Woodland Tradition (OWT) Villages to be subject to salvage excavation in Northern Iroquoia. In this innovative study, Finlayson and Lerner provide a detailed study of the chronology, culture history and settlement patterns of the Keffer site and 28 other Black Creek and Realignment Substage sites on the Don and Upper Rouge Rivers.
Keffer was a 1.6 ha village occupied by Iroquoians and Anishinabek between about A.D. 1526 and 1550. Results of this study propose a new sequence of the growth of the village during Construction, Initial and Final Occupation Phases, new perspectives on defensive strategies in the planning of the village throughout its occupation. Five clusters of houses have been identified within the village with chief’s houses present in four of these. The study of the 18 longhouses and four Anishinabek wigwams provides new evidence for the occupation of Keffer by both Iroquoian and Anishinabek peoples. An in-depth study of the large number sweat bath structures in the central corridors of the longhouses suggests that three of the longhouses were probably occupied by Anishinabek peoples.
Read more
On a broader scale, Finlayson and Lerner define four communities of OWT peoples who occupied the Don and Upper Rouge rivers during the Black Creek substage, before coalescing to create the Keffer site. The changes in the occupation between the Black Creek substage and the Realignment substages are detailed as are the similarities to the contemporaneously occupied Draper Coalescent village on the Duffin Creek to east. The study further details the significance of frontiers on the Duffin Creek and the Niagara Escarpment with a later frontier on the Humber River as key to understanding the OWT occupation of the central and western northern shore of Lake Ontario.
The study emphasizes the importance of using ‘old data’ in writing archaeological histories and the need to have a firm grasp on chronology, culture history and settlement patterns before the investigation of problems of broader anthropological interest.
This volume presents an analysis and interpretation of the Keffer site settlement patterns. The Keffer site, an early 16 th century Huron-Wendat/Anishinabek village, was fully excavated as a CRM project almost 50 years ago under the direction of the senior author. This publication provides a detailed investigation of the site from a settlement pattern approach, covering ancillary structures (sweat baths), houses and palisades, settlement layout, and regional context. Data is laid out in a series of tables, graphs, and over 200 full-colour house and site plans. The Keffer site along with 28 other sites in the Don and Upper Rouge drainages in the Toronto region, dating to the late 15th and 16th century, are arranged hronologically in regional sequences, based on settlement duration, population, and occupational histories of individual sites. It offers the most current history of Huron-Wendat/Anishinabek interaction on the north shore of Lake Ontario ca. 1475-1550. This book will become one of the classic references for future research on the Indigenous landscape of 15 th and 16 th century southern Ontario.
Gary Warrick, Ph.D.,
Professor Emeritus,
Wilfrid Laurier University
This data-rich volume examines the Keffer site, a frontier village of the Ontario Woodland Tradition, excavated by Finlayson during his tenure at the London Museum of Archaeology (now the Museum of Ontario Archaeology). Through the re-evaluation of legacy collections, the application of modern technologies, and the integration of Indigenous perspectives, the authors challenge traditional interpretations about ancestral Anishinabek and Iroquoian interactions, situating Keffer within a broader context of 29 archaeological sites along the Don and Upper Rouge River drainages. Featuring 48 tables of data and 228 full-color maps, The Keffer Site lays a foundation for future research, offering multiple interpretations and fostering a shared understanding of the complex histories that continue to shape this region now recognized as the Greater Toronto Area (GTA) of southern Ontario.
Rhonda Bathurst, Ph.D.,
Museum of Ontario Archaeology
This volume reports on the extensive settlement data from the Keffer site including detailed descriptions of longhouses, sweat baths, and ancillary structures including likely Anishinabek wigwams.
An early chapter provides an history of investigation of the site and summaries of the numerous significant studies carried out by other scholars. The high-quality figures and tables will facilitate use by students and researchers for their own comparative purposes. However, this volume is far more than a site report. Comparisons are made between the Draper and Keffer sites, two contemporaneous sixteenth century coalescent villages located in the central north shore of Lake Ontario. Re-evaluation of existing data by the authors situates these sites in a rapidly evolving social and political landscape. Much is accomplished with this volume, not the least of which is laying the groundwork for future research.
Anyone perusing this book will be struck by the myriad possibilities for future archaeological research in the province of Ontario and beyond.
William Engelbrecht, Ph.D.
November 2024
The Keffer Site: Suplementary Volume
Strategic Initiatives in the Defense of Palisaded Ontario Woodland Tradition Villages
The publication of Volume 4 represents the next step in the development of the Occasional Papers series. Going forward the volumes will appear only as ebooks.